OT - I don't _hate_ McMansions

Josh Coates jcoates at gmail.com
Tue Jun 24 10:14:31 MDT 2008

ugh - this list moves too fast for me - i can't keep up with all these
delicious strawmen just asking to be beat down!  ;-)

but let me just squash one quick fallacy that keeps being repeated by
several folks here.

newsflash: the government *already* regulates lot and house sizes.  so, save
all your "free market purity" blather for the fictional free market that
lives in mailing list hypotheticals and econ textbooks.

yeah, that's right - check with your local city and/or talk to a developer -
they will tell you that the city and county tells them how big and how small
their lots can be, and how large their houses can be.

why do these laws exist?  to keeps our communities from becoming the ugly
byproducts of short-term gain from developers.  the local elected officials
regulate the local housing development market - weird, huh?

developers aren't dumb - they look at the laws, they look at their plot map,
pick out the cheapest (but shiny!) materials, do some quick math and
optimize to maximize the dollar, and then the realtors come in and advise
them on what is most immediately sellable, and not necessarily the most
livable place to build, and ta-da!  high-density mcmansion housing!

my primary complaint is that they are doing a lame job at maintaining these
laws, and they should probably revise the current laws on the books to keep
up with those greedy (yes, greedy i say - because they sacrifice the common
good for money, which i define as greedy jbellis!!) developers that are
optimizing their practices against the current laws.


More information about the PLUG mailing list