Advantages of Fiber

Nicholas Leippe nick at
Thu Sep 27 16:52:25 MDT 2007

On Thursday 27 September 2007, Kyle Waters wrote:
> I think he was just comparing it to UTOPIA.  Spanish Fork was being used
> as an example(by senator stephenson) of why the state should ban all
> cities from bonding for telecommunications infrastructure.  I need
> counter arguments :).

Counter arguments? When I lived there it was fantastic.
Everyone I know who lives there still think it's very good.

Perhaps he should talk to the guy in SF that's in charge of the project. When 
I spoke with him years ago, he explained that the entire project stayed in 
the black throughout the entire deployment process--which only took a few 
years to cover the entire city. Talk about well managed financially and 

Compared to commercial offerings (qwest DSL or Comcast/AT&T) they were better 
all around:
- Qwest couldn't even do DSL to my home because their field office was
  already multiplexing.
- They provide a better infrastructure than Comcast--much lower number of
  amplifiers per node (I think it was six-fold--a max of one amplifier per
  node as opposed to Comcast's six)
- They provided (when I was there) higher speeds (3Mbit as opposed to 1.5,
  and since then if I am not mistaken they have doubled it, at no extra
- They provided excellent customer service--try getting any decent customer
  service from Comcast. Examples:

Me: "Can I get a static IP"
SF: "How many do you want?"

Me: "I'm having connection troubles"
SF: "We'll be there in 15-30 minutes."
Later that day, SF: "we had a port go flaky, it'll be fixed by morning."

Compare to Comcast (when I was in California, so maybe it's not fair):
Me: "I'm having connection troubles"
Comcast, after waiting on hold for 30 minutes: "reboot your modem, sir"
Comcast, after reboot does nothing: "I'm sorry sir, I can't help you. Let me 
schedule for a tech to come out sometime this week..."

Maybe it's not for every city government, but IMO Spanish Fork really got it 
right on this one.


More information about the PLUG mailing list